Posted by: @nirmalsailor@ | April 27, 2011

Three Idiots Vs Nanban

This slideshow requires JavaScript.


After a Mega budget movie “Enthiran”, Director Shankar’s next project will be the remake of the movie “Three Idiots”. As of now the film is titled as “Nanban”, starring by Illaya thalabathi “Vijay”, Jeeva and Srikanth. This will be Shankar’s first remake movie. He is one of the leading directors in Kollywood. So far he have directed “Gentle man”, “kadhalan”, “Indian”, “Jeans”, “Mudhalvan”, “Boys”, “Anniyan”, “Shivaji” and “Enthiran”. These heavy budget movies are block busters in Tamil Nadu. Now Shankar joined with Vijay. This increases our expectation. Music directed by “Harris”. He is joining with Harris after the movie “Anniyan”. Let us hope for good collection of songs for this movie. But this is a challenge for Director “Shankar” because most of the people would have seen the 3 IDIOTS. But the great question is “How he is going to handle the movie in order to satisfy all class of people?”
It is our culture to have more fights, romantic songs and a comedian to entertain the people. Unfortunately 3 Idiots is not that kind of Commercial movie. So their discussion will be how to include the additional fights and romantic songs to an existing story. Director Shankar is an expert for producing the photo copy of the stunt sequence from a Hollywood movie. But in this case he needs to think about the story he is going insert in order to make it commercial. Most probably we can expect some scenes like a Politian son studying in college or X lover of the heroin (As per the story of 3 Idiots) will arrange some dadas to kill Vijay. If something is added similar to what I mention, then sure it will disappoint ‘A’ class. On the other hand, all the idiots Aamir Khan, Madhavan and Sharman Joshi in 3 idiots have equal importance through out the movie. In our case Vijay should be treated in a special way, other wise thalabathi fans will get disappointed. Of course “Srikanth” and “Jeeva” are having less number of fans compare to vijay. Role of “Amir khan” will be played “Vijay” for sure. Question is about who will play the Role of “Madahavan” and “Sharman Joshi”. I can’t guess it. While thinking about heroine, Ileana is playing the role of “Kareena kapoor”. So far kollywood is unaware of Ileana’s acting. Her appearance in the KD movie has not impressed tamil audience. 3 Idiots movie is partially based on the story written by Chetan bhagat. I am damn sure that the story will be in an irregular shape compare to the original version. It is in the hands of the director Shankar to make the irregular version of 3 idiots as a commercial one. Let’s have a hope that Mr. Vijay will not have hard punch dialogue in this movie. He should not. Most of the scene I am expecting to see  in tamil version are  “Intelligent guy blabbering some in the stage”, “Marriage drop at climax” and “Drunken Idiots at the principal house at midnight”. Hope this scenes are no need to get altered in the new version. Remaking a commercial hit movie is not a big deal. As director “Raja” is an expert in directing those. But remaking the classic movies like “3 Idiots” is definitely a big challenge. Dr. Shankar needs to overcome the challenge. He should give a good feast to all kind of classes. Vijay is busy in doing the movie “Velayutham”. Shooting of the movie “Nanban” will be started once the Velayudam has been completed. After a long time people will be seeing a tamil movie having three heroes at the silver screen. Shankar usually takes 2 years for a movie. What about this project?

Advertisement

Responses

  1. For your kind information, 3 Idiots shooting already started and finished first schedule in ooty, second in Dehra Dun and third now in chennai, recently happened in sky walk. Vijay – Aamir Khan, Jeeva – Saraman Joshi, Srikanth – Madhavan. Sathyaraj – Principal, apart from Ileana Anuya is there. Sj Surya is the other student apart from three. Raghava Lawrence is the original student on whose identity Vijay will come. And shankar decided not to change much of the scenes as the originality will be lost. But he is striving to remove the hindi flavour for fitting to Tamil Audience. And Vijay has no punch dialogues. And Velayutham to be released on june 22 and audio expected from May 14 with trailers from May.

  2. Then what is the release date of this movie..?
    I Hope the tamil version of 3 Idiots will be a great Mokkai..

    • Releasing this diwali…. And i wonder when did you join the production crew to tell the result now itself

  3. No, not like that. I said I hope.. i didn’t said it will be…
    But Compare to Hindi version of 3 Idiots.. Tamil version will be some what scanty and flimsy!!!

  4. ivlo pesura nee, even you will not like if the movie is taken as it is in hindi.. Because when people speak tamil certain things needs to be changed

  5. I accept that.. He should remove some scenes which reflects the north Indian culture and to replace it with south Indian…

    But the something will be missing in the Tamil version compare to Hindi version..

    Atha othuko.. 3 idiots padam pathavanga kandeepa ipdi than feel pannuvanga

  6. In original version they have missed many scenes from the story that is written by Chetan Bhagat. I would be better that if shankar adds those missed scenes to this new version in tamil…

  7. Appdi avangalukku andha feeling vandhuda koodaadhunudhaa Shankar decided not to change much from original one. He is going to add one song, change the flavour. Avlodhaa. He takes up not to give the feel of hindi but tamil. But he decided not to allow people think whether this scene is removed, that scene is removed, this was better in hindi, that was better in tamil.

  8. @ RAM KUMAR: I think that will not happen

    @ MADAN: That allows us see how much Dr. Shankar is talented…

  9. I hope he might add some scenes but not delete any scenes….

  10. Shankar is always talented in making audience satisfied. He does something besides to make the front end create a look and feel

  11. @MADAN : Front end…look and feel….nee java la work pandra nu nalla theriyudhu….


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.